fb


Wife’s Property Rights in India

Wife’s Property Rights in India

Introduction

The legal guidelines that govern property ownership and use are known as property rights. They defend the rights and interests of people and organizations and serve as the cornerstone of the legal system. Because they offer incentives for investment and output, property rights are crucial to the economy's operation.

What are a wife's legal rights of property over a husband?

The Supreme Court ruled in the well-known Shah Bano case that, under Section 3 (1Ha) of the Muslim Women (Protection of Rights on Divorce) Act, 1986, the husband must provide a reasonable and equitable means of providing for his ex-wife's maintenance even after they have separated. Since the lady is still in charge of her possessions, this time frame goes beyond iddat. If her husband passes away, a widow receives one-eighth of the estate (if she has children) and one-fourth if nothing. The portion could drop to one-sixteenth if there are multiple wives.

The Hindu Marriage Act of 1955 governs the property rights of married Hindu women in India. According to this Act, both spouses have an equal claim to any property obtained by one of them during the marriage, and it is considered joint property. This implies that married women are not subject to discrimination in their access to property and have the same rights to it as married males. 

This rule does have some exceptions, though. For instance, the Act stipulates that anything given to a woman as a dowry by her in-laws is her personal property and cannot be reclaimed by her husband. Furthermore, the Act states that if a woman inherits property from her parents, it is her property and cannot be claimed by her husband.

All the rights of the wife in the husband’s property in India

The first Indian law to acknowledge married women's property rights was the Special Marriage Act of 1954. This law gave married couples legal protection for their property rights and permitted them to register their union. Along with giving married spouses the right to maintenance and alimony, the statute permitted divorce and remarriage.

Is a wife eligible for her husband's ancestral property in India, as per the Hindu Marriage Act?

A Hindu wife is not entitled to inherit her husband's ancestral property under Hindu law. After her husband's passing, a wife may, nevertheless, inherit his portion of the family estate. This occurs when the husband passes away before his ancestral property has been divided. Furthermore, if a husband passes away after receiving his portion of the family's assets, the assets will be equally divided between the deceased's wife or spouse and their offspring.

What are the second wife's rights to property in India?

The second wife will not be able to claim any of her first husband's inherited property if the law does not recognize the marriage. However, this does not apply if the husband has the right to a second wife in property that he has acquired on his own.

He would be liberated to leave it to whomever he intended, even the second wife, by using a will. However, if a person dies without leaving a will (a situation known as "intestate" in legalese), his possessions will be divided among his legal heirs by the laws of succession.

The second marriage will have legal sanction and the second wife will be entitled to all of her husband's property, both self-acquired and inherited, if it occurs after the first wife's divorce or death. Conversely, if the second marriage occurs before the first wife's divorce or death or it is not legally sanctioned then it will instead come under her husband's Class-1 heirs.

Can a wife claim her husband's property during a divorce?

The issue of property rights for divorced women in India is complex, as it depends on which type of marriage the woman is in. In a Hindu marriage, as per the provisions of the Hindu Marriage Act, of 1955, any property acquired by either spouse during the marriage is deemed to be joint property and that both spouses have an equal right to it. This means that if a woman is divorced, she is entitled to a half share of the property. 

However, the situation is different for Muslim marriages. As per the Muslim Personal Law (Shariat) Application Act, 1937, a woman who is divorced from her husband is not entitled to a share of the property. Instead, the property is divided between the husband and the wife's family. 

How does property division work for a wife and husband in India during a divorce?

The division is based on the following factors –

1.    Equity: Based on the fact that it is more necessary, the division is governed by the equity principle. 

2.    Ownership: The purchase of real estate is based on who is the owner of the title or whose name the property is registered under.

3.    Contribution: IToget ownership, the individual must provide substantial proof of his involvement.

Even though the property was registered in his wife's name, the husband in the Debika Chakraborty v. Pradeep Chakraborty case demonstrated his contribution to it. He was able to demonstrate that he had a fiduciary relationship with the property and that he had appointed his wife as its trustee. After taking into account his arguments, the Calcutta High Court issued a ruling in the husband's favour, granting him ownership of the land. 

If the husband and wife jointly own the property, it may be claimed that the property will be divided during the divorce. The court distributes it based on each party's contribution and share. The court considers the husband's contribution when granting him a portion of the property if it is owned entirely by the wife. The husband is required to provide compelling proof to support his contribution because the court typically does not permit it.

Conclusion

As we can comprehend, Indian society considers marriage a holy sacrament, which is likely one of the reasons why there is a legal loophole that would allow a wife to collect her husband's assets following a divorce. Section 20 of the Indian Succession Act, 1925 states that no one who marries gains any ownership interest in the other person's property. Because of this, she typically cannot claim a portion of her husband's assets during a divorce. The law stipulates that the husband must pay the woman alimony in the event of a divorce. 

However, a wife is not entitled to her husband's property explicitly under any such legal rule. Since they were considered "ani-male," certain bills that were introduced on this topic have lapsed. However, subject to the different laws governing succession and inheritance, a wife's inheritance of her husband's property typically happens upon his death.

Author:

Disha Chauhan
Delhi, India
Campus Law Centre, University of Delhi, Final Year Law


Leave a Comment



Previous Comments


Related Blogs